Man gets 2-year jail for calling wife 'black'

started by tiramisu 6 mnths ago
The world has gone PC crazy!

Reply



Flat Nested

Replies


  Uppili posted Re:Man gets 2-year jail for calling wife 'black' on 6 mnths ago
This is the case in marriages that does not have whole hearted acceptance of the other person - with the negatives.   It is sad that the woman died... Usually the victims are always nice, sensitive,and accomodating people - male or female. Naturally they become gullible and perennially hopeful even in impossible situation.

2 years is too little... I am sure she was not criticized just by the husband - but also probably by the in-laws... But, I am even surprised that this came to court - bcz this involves MINORITIES. The Mullahs would have hushed it up had she survived.
  Gatita posted Re:Man gets 2-year jail for calling wife on 6 mnths ago

 

Correct these assholes say all they want to her making her dead inside what was she supposed to do tell me?
She was sensitive too much I think that is why she did not took revenge against him and continue on to her suicide...
Poor think I can imagine her pain; I heard once a similar case but this time the man received the penalty of the state which is to be shoot in the head against a concrete wall…
 
Gatita*
  Job less fella posted Re:Man gets 2-year jail for calling wife on 6 mnths ago
this is against human nature..a man's nature is to control his woman...
we cannot forget our animal instincts,,it is just to uncivilized to forget...that we are ultimately mere animals...
  Gatita posted Re:Man gets 2-year jail for calling wife on 6 mnths ago
oh really and animals also love so does humans point?





  sara Boji posted Re:Man gets 2-year jail for calling wife 'black' on 6 mnths ago
Why is it 'PC crazy' for the judge to put this fellow in jail?

He mentally totured her and drove her to commit suicide.
  Merlot Daruwala posted Re:Man gets 2-year jail for calling wife on 6 mnths ago

When one goes only by the suicide note, there can't be any objective definition of "mental torture". What if someone commits suicide saying her spouse tortured her by wearing badly mismatched clothes all the time - is that sufficient grounds to prosecute the spouse? As per the current judgement, the answer is yes because we don't know how much of mental agony the wife suffered from her husband's bad dress-sense, and have only her word to go by.

  Uppili posted Re:Man gets 2-year jail for calling wife on 6 mnths ago
I am pretty sure, they would have called in other witnesses and the defendent's lawyer would have cross examined them. Usually, such men are not discrete and do call names in front of others.  The suicide note initiated the case, but not a ruling by itself.
  Merlot Daruwala posted Re:Man gets 2-year jail for calling wife on 6 mnths ago
I see. You are pretty sure there were other witnesses to the abuse and in the same sentence, you acknowledge that the "abuse" would not have happened in front of others. So I suppose the witnesses came in to testify about the weather on the day of the suicide, the clothes everyone wore on that day and such other extremely important matters. Yes, definitely an open and shut case.

Pls answer my question - is it mental torture if a spouse insists on displaying his or her terrible sense of dress-sense? If not, why not? Shouldn't the victim of the torture be the one who decides that?

  Uppili posted Re:Man gets 2-year jail for calling wife on 6 mnths ago
And you are sure the judge took one look at the suicide note and sentenced him to 2 years on the spot?

First answer this as this is subject of the thread. Then we can talk about his off-track hypothetical dress-sense example.
  Merlot Daruwala posted Re:Man gets 2-year jail for calling wife on 6 mnths ago

Ok - I can't think of any, so you tell me what possible evidence can there be in a case of mental harassment by a husband on a wife. Since you are clearly very knowledgeable on what the judge based his decision on, please enlighten the rest of us as well so we don't labor under the belief that the judge was being silly.

The original point raised by this ruling is what constitutes mental torture. So the hypothetical scenario I raise is very germane to the case. If you can't see the link, stop taxing that poor lonesome grey cell of yours and stick to what you are most comfortable with i.e. baiting mullahs.







  Merlot Daruwala posted Re:Man gets 2-year jail for calling wife on 6 mnths ago

Yeah, this is a truly silly judgement. On the plus side, I suppose Peacegazer can use this legal precedent to silence his nagging wife instead of whining about it on CH.



© 1998-2008 Copyright Sulekha.com Connecting Indians Worldwide, All Rights Reserved.

Embed Videos

TipTip: To embed video from YouTube or others, copy the embed URL given and click insert button.

Title:             

Embed script:

Insert